Competition and strengthening the single market
By Brian McHugh, Chair
Originally published in the Business Post on European Consumer Day, Wednesday 28 October 2026
Competition and growth
In 2013, when the European Commission blocked Ryanair's proposed acquisition of Aer Lingus for the third time, the budget airline argued the decision was political, rather than a concern about monopolised air travel in and out of Ireland.
But the decision was firmly based on the evidence, and the result of the block was that both companies continued to battle fiercely for business, to the benefit of Irish and international consumers alike.
Ryanair went on to become Europe's largest airline, carrying in excess of 200 million passengers per annum. Aer Lingus carried a record number of passengers in 2025, often providing Irish consumers with choice. The decision drove competition for both airlines.
Today, as part of Ireland’s Presidency of the EU, leaders of competition authorities across Europe as well as leading competition academics and lawyers will come together, to mark European Competition Day and discuss how we can all make the case for strong competition policy.
We will also be discussing the European Commission’s plans to update their merger guidelines later this year. This might sound like a niche policy discussion for die hard competition nerds, but Europe is at a crossroads and merger policy at the heart of decision making on future direction.
Faced with subsidies in the US and state-backed competitors in China, as well as growing geopolitical uncertainty, there are calls for Europe to strengthen its competitiveness by relaxing its merger regime and expanding state aid to create EU ‘champion’ companies.
It sounds tempting. Europe needs stronger growth, greater innovation and a more resilient economy. But weakening merger policy in an attempt to drive this would be a mistake. And run contrary to economic history.
The Single Market
First things first, we should ask ourselves, ‘what has increased Europe’s living standards over the decades?’ The answer to that is not state-backed super companies. The answer is the Single Market. For more than three decades, the Single Market has been Europe's most successful economic project. It has opened up national economies, including Ireland’s. It has reduced barriers to trade and investment, created a market of almost 450 million consumers and allowed businesses to scale across borders.
Ryanair may not admire regulatory agencies like ours, but we view them as an enormous success story. Ryanair was built on competition, on access to larger markets and stronger competitive incentives.
The European Commission’s block of Ryanair’s attempt to acquire a rival did not hold it back. Merger control does not stop companies from growing. It ensures that size does not come at the expense of competition, innovation and consumers.
In fact, the vast majority of mergers reviewed by competition authorities are cleared.
Removing barriers to growth
In my view, the challenge facing Europe today is not excessive competition between companies that are too small and need a state-backed boost. Rather, it is because the Single Market needs to be deepened.
To take an example banking and capital markets remain largely national, keeping them fragmented. As well as being frustrating for consumers who would like more banking choices this is a drag for businesses. It is not a coincidence that businesses such as Google and Meta and more recently Nvidia and Open AI have grown into global titans with the support of the continent-wide US capital market.
Encouragingly, in Ireland, this challenge is receiving renewed political attention. Ahead of assuming the Presidency of the Council of the European Union, the Government placed Single Market reform at the centre of its competitiveness agenda. Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, Peter Burke has noted that businesses continue to face fragmented rules that constrain trade, competition and growth across Europe. He has called for the Single Market to work "in practice, not just in theory" and wants to see any barriers that prevent businesses from growing and competing across the EU to be broken down.
It is my view that if Europe wants companies capable of competing globally, one of the most effective steps it can take is to deepen integration within the Single Market. Completing the Savings and Investment Union would improve access to finance and unlock investment. More simplified and harmonised regulations would create new opportunities for companies to enter and expand across borders and achieve scale.
In a nutshell, Europe could smooth the path for businesses that want to grow by creating an even more integrated market, rather than relaxing time-tested merger rules or allowing larger countries to create sluggish, state-aid dependent companies.
For a small, open economy such as Ireland, this really matters. Europe's strength has always rested on common rules and a level playing field, where a business can succeed whether it is from Galway or Berlin.
Competition is good for business
None of this means Europe should be passive. It must respond to unfair trade practices, foreign subsidies and economic coercion. It must strengthen economic security and support strategic sectors. But it should do so without forgetting one of the central lessons of European economic history; competition is good for business.

