My expensive new handbag bought on an online marketplace is not what was advertised to me - what are my rights?
Q: I recently bought an expensive handbag through an online marketplace. However, when it arrived, it looked nothing like the photos and the quality was much poorer than advertised. I contacted the website, but they told me the handbag was sold by a seller based in Germany and that I needed to deal with them directly. Surely the website has some responsibility? What are my rights?
- Ailbhe, Galway
It’s really annoying to receive something that isn’t what you expected, particularly when you’ve spent a lot of money on it.
When you shop through an online marketplace, it’s easy to assume you’re buying directly from the website. However, many marketplaces act as a middleman, allowing other businesses and individuals to sell products through their platform. This means your contract may actually be with the seller rather than the marketplace itself.
The first thing to do is check your order confirmation and the product listing to see who actually sold you the handbag.
If the seller is a business, you have rights under Irish and EU consumer law. Products must match their description, and if something isn’t as advertised, you’re generally entitled to a remedy.
If the handbag is significantly different from what was advertised, you may be entitled to a refund. In other cases, the seller may first have the opportunity to put things right, for example by offering a repair or replacement. Depending on the circumstances, a price reduction may also be an option.
Your next step should be to contact the seller in writing, explain the problem and include photographs of the handbag alongside screenshots of the original listing. It’s also worth checking whether the marketplace has its own complaints process or buyer protection policy.
One important thing to be aware of is the difference between buying from a business and a private seller. If you’re buying from another individual selling their own belongings, the same consumer protections generally don’t apply, and getting your money back can be more difficult.
Online marketplaces are required to tell you whether a seller is a business or a private individual, so it’s always worth checking this before making a purchase.
As the seller in your case is based in Germany, you can also contact the European Consumer Centre Ireland (ECC Ireland) for free advice and assistance with your cross-border complaint. You’ll generally need to have raised the issue with the seller first but if you haven’t been able to resolve it, ECC Ireland may be able to work with its counterparts in Germany to help you reach a resolution.
While online marketplaces offer plenty of choice and convenience, it’s important to know who you’re buying from and what protections are available to you.
The above article originally appeared in the Sunday Independent on 15 November 2026: Your questions answered: ‘The English-language school I attend has gone bust. Can I get my fees back?’ | Irish Independent
